The Guessing Game

Listener Spotlight


Every episode, Michael drops a series of intentionally difficult clues about where new listeners are tuning in from β€” geography, landmarks, history, or something obscure enough to make you say, "How would anyone know that?" Crack the clues, send in your guess below, and earn your place in the winner's circle.

Submit Your Guess
The Archive

The Clues & The Reveals

Current Mystery Β· S5E16 Β· Clues given July 4, 2026 Β· "Bucket Hats, Beanie Babies…"

Can You Crack It?

Answer Revealed after the Tour de France mini-series β€” get your guess in!
β€” Season Five β€”
S5E15 β†’ S5E16 Β· Clues given June 17 Β· Revealed July 4, 2026

Powell, Tennessee

AnswerPowell, TN

Bricks of Beaver Creek mud earned the nickname; settler Stockley Donaldson was Andrew Jackson's brother-in-law; and it all started as the Powell Station railroad stop. One guess came in β€” Abilene, Kansas β€” not quite.

S5E13 β†’ S5E15 Β· Clues given May 22 Β· Revealed June 17, 2026 β€” the 100th episode

Omaha, Nebraska

AnswerOmaha, NE

πŸ† Winners: Paul from Columbia, Missouri (whose fan mail also demanded β€” and got β€” the new Listener Spotlight jingle) and Armando. Founded at a July 4, 1854 picnic; Gerald Ford is the only Eagle Scout president; the Reuben was born at the Blackstone Hotel; Swanson invented the TV dinner; the Henry Doorly Zoo has an indoor rainforest; and Malcolm X was born there.

S5E12 β†’ S5E13 Β· Clues given May 8 Β· Revealed May 22, 2026

Northampton, England

AnswerNorthampton, England

πŸ† Winners: Jeff and his wife Heather, via voice fan mail. Alex Bell's Cardiff guess was a noble near-miss. Medieval escape tunnels, 23 million pairs of WWI boots, Doctor Who's Matt Smith, the Black Death, and the Great Fire of 1675.

S5E11 β†’ S5E12 Β· Clues given April 24 Β· Revealed May 8, 2026

Palestine, Texas

AnswerPalestine, TX

Founded 1846 and named after Palestine, Illinois β€” and home to NASA's Columbia Scientific Balloon Facility, which is very serious about balloons indeed.

S5E10 β†’ S5E11 Β· Clues given April 10 Β· Revealed April 24, 2026

Milwaukee, Wisconsin

AnswerMilwaukee, WI

πŸ† Flawless victory β€” all five guessers got it: Alex Bell (the first-ever voice fan mail guess), Wade Paul, Mark, Matt, and Armando. Wayne's World's "the good land," Pabst Blue Ribbon, and Teddy Roosevelt finishing his speech after being shot.

S5E9 β†’ S5E10 Β· Clues given March 27 Β· Revealed April 10, 2026

Eddyville, Kentucky

AnswerEddyville, KY

Nobody cracked this one β€” a rare shutout. Eddyville is named for the eddies in the Cumberland River, settled in 1798, and best known for the "Castle on the Cumberland" (the Kentucky State Penitentiary). The whole town relocated in 1959 for the construction of a dam; its Colorado tie is native son John L. Routt, two-time governor of Colorado; and it has served as the county seat of three different counties.

S5E8 β†’ S5E9 Β· Clues given March 13 Β· Revealed March 27, 2026

Fayetteville, North Carolina

AnswerFayetteville, NC

πŸ† Winner: Wade β€” who lived there through two deployments and bought his first dog off the side of Skibo Road. Campbellton and Cross Creek united, named for Lafayette, home of the Airborne and special operations.

S5E7 β†’ S5E8 Β· Clues given February 27 Β· Revealed March 13, 2026

Ashburn, Virginia

AnswerAshburn, VA

Once called Farmwell, now the data-center capital of the world, grown by Dulles Airport β€” and soul legend Wilson Pickett lived there at the end of his life. One brave guess of Littleton, Colorado came up short.

S5E6 β†’ S5E7 Β· Clues given February 13 Β· Revealed February 27, 2026

Yuma, Arizona

AnswerYuma, AZ

The Colorado River crossing, the Yuma Proving Ground's parachute testing (that's the free falling), America's winter lettuce capital, and officially the sunniest place in the United States.

S5E5 β†’ S5E6 Β· Clues given February 1 Β· Revealed February 13, 2026

Pensacola, Florida

AnswerPensacola, FL β€” the City of Five Flags

No correct guesses β€” Adam went with Detroit and stood by it.

S5E4 β†’ S5E5 Β· Clues given January 18 Β· Revealed February 1, 2026

Birmingham, Alabama

AnswerBirmingham, AL β€” "The Magic City"

The only place on Earth with iron, coal, and limestone side by side β€” and where Dr. King wrote his Letter from Birmingham Jail. Adam guessed Pittsburgh. Twice.

S5E3 β†’ S5E4 Β· Bonus clues given January 6 Β· Revealed January 18, 2026

Marshall, Illinois

AnswerMarshall, IL

Home of the oldest continuously operating community band in the U.S., and a stone arch built by the Army Corps of Engineers (1828–1837) without a drop of concrete. No guesses on this bonus round.

S5E2 β†’ S5E4 Β· Clues given January 4 Β· Revealed January 18, 2026

Frankfurt, Germany

AnswerFrankfurt, Germany

πŸ† Winners: Matt and Jeff β€” both nailed it. First international spotlight, home of the world's largest book fair and the original frankfurter. "You hot dog."

S4E28 β†’ S5E2 Β· Clues given December 21, 2025 Β· Revealed January 4, 2026

Rancho Palos Verdes, California

AnswerRancho Palos Verdes, CA

πŸ† Winners: Matt and Armando β€” both spotted the golf course that slid into the Pacific in 1999 and the Lethal Weapon filming locations.

β€” Season Four β€”
S4E26 β†’ S4E28 Β· Clues given December 9 Β· Revealed December 21, 2025

Mesa, Arizona

AnswerMesa, AZ

πŸ† Winner: Keith. Alex earned half points for landing just 20 miles away. Hohokam canals over a thousand years old, fiercely protected saguaros, and Cactus League spring training. For our fans in Mesa: don't cut down any cactus.

S4E25 β†’ S4E26 Β· Clues given November 23 Β· Revealed December 9, 2025

Tucker, Georgia

AnswerTucker, GA

Military District 572 (later DeKalb County), 13 cemeteries within four miles, and Steve Walsh β€” vocalist of the band Kansas β€” calls it home. Armando's guess of Bentonville, Arkansas earned points for cycling taste, but not for accuracy.

S4E24 β†’ S4E25 Β· Clues given November 9 Β· Revealed November 23, 2025

Waltham, Massachusetts

AnswerWaltham, MA β€” "Watch City"

πŸ† Winner: Matt Robinson. Armando went Newark, Alex went Lancaster PA. Born from Watertown in 1738, birthplace of integrated manufacturing, home of the Bleachery and the Chemistry β€” and the Waltham Watch Company, which made 35 million watches.

S4E23 β†’ S4E24 Β· Clues posted online after October 26 Β· Revealed November 9, 2025

Fort Payne, Alabama

AnswerFort Payne, AL

πŸ† The first-ever FOUR winners on one mystery: Wade Paul, Alex Bell, Matt Robinson (who offered to eat his socks if wrong β€” he owns 300+ pairs), and Armando.

S4E22 β†’ S4E23 Β· Clues given October 12 Β· Revealed October 26, 2025

Fort Wayne, Indiana

AnswerFort Wayne, IN

No correct guesses β€” Adam worked through Pittsburgh and Boston before losing.

S4E21 β†’ S4E22 Β· Clues given October 2 Β· Revealed October 12, 2025

Prescott, Arizona

AnswerPrescott, AZ

New guesser Terry Donaldson from Largo, FL went Cimarron, NM β€” wrong, but "right part of the country" (Michael spent five summers at nearby Philmont Scout Ranch).

S4E20 β†’ S4E21 Β· Clues given September 14 Β· Revealed October 2, 2025

Bay City, Michigan

AnswerBay City, MI

Michael's home-state pick for Adam. Wrong guess: David Stroud β€” Newport News, VA. The Bay City Rollers, it turns out, are from Edinburgh.

S4E19 β†’ S4E20 Β· Clues given August 31 Β· Revealed September 14, 2025

Bismarck, North Dakota

AnswerBismarck, ND

Wrong guess: Tony from Caldwell, ID β€” Manhattan, KS (about an hour from Michael's house).

S4E18 β†’ S4E19 Β· Clues given August 17 Β· Revealed August 31, 2025

Johnson City, Tennessee

AnswerJohnson City, TN

πŸ† Winner: Wade Paul, with a mic-drop clue-by-clue answer.

S4E17 β†’ S4E18 Β· Clues given August 3 Β· Revealed August 17, 2025 β€” episode 75

Atlanta, Illinois

AnswerAtlanta, IL

Partial credit: Matt Robinson β€” Vienna, IL. Right state, wrong town, silent S intentionally pronounced.

S4E16 β†’ S4E17 Β· Clues given July 20 Β· Revealed August 3, 2025

New Hope, Pennsylvania

AnswerNew Hope, PA

Wrong guess: Matthew from Ohio (the friend who rescued their bike boxes at their first Big BRAG) β€” Wheeling, WV.

S4E15 β†’ S4E16 Β· Clues given July 6 Β· Revealed July 20, 2025

Grafton, Wisconsin

AnswerGrafton, WI

Wrong guess: Tom from Utah β€” Sioux Falls, SD.

S4E15 reveal Β· Clues posted during the June BRAG break Β· Revealed July 6, 2025

Rome, Italy

AnswerRome, Italy

An international curveball. Wrong guesses: Trip Barker β€” Hartwell, GA; Adam β€” Toccoa, GA. Adam demanded the challenge flag.

S4E11 β†’ S4E12 Β· Clues given May 11 Β· Revealed May 25, 2025

Huntsville, Alabama

AnswerHuntsville, AL

πŸ† ADAM'S FIRST-EVER WIN β€” "after like 60 of these" β€” called in two minutes after recording; plus Wade Paul and Jeff (whose wife figured it out). Alex Bell's Lexington, VA: a beautifully reasoned wrong answer.

S4E10 β†’ S4E11 Β· Clues given April 27 Β· Revealed May 11, 2025

Naples, Florida

AnswerNaples, FL

πŸ† Winner: Armando ("I don't get to do this very often" β€” Michael). Wrong: Matt Robinson β€” Yuma; Melanie Erickson and Adam β€” The Villages; Jeff β€” Venice, FL.

S4E9 β†’ S4E10 Β· Clues given April 13 Β· Revealed April 27, 2025

Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

AnswerBroken Arrow, OK

No correct guesses; Adam: St. Louis ("not close"). Dedicated to the listeners who had been there since roughly episode two.

S4E8 β†’ S4E9 Β· Clues given March 30 Β· Revealed April 13, 2025

Hampton, New Hampshire

AnswerHampton, NH

Wrong guess: Al β€” Atlantic City, NJ; close regionally. New listeners welcomed that episode from the Netherlands, Portugal, Hungary, and Belize.

S4E7 β†’ S4E8 Β· Clues given March 16 Β· Revealed March 30, 2025

Marmaduke, Arkansas

AnswerMarmaduke, AR

Very close guess: Johnny β€” New Madrid/Sikeston, MO, the quake's epicenter.

S4E6 β†’ S4E7 Β· Clues given March 2 Β· Revealed March 16, 2025

South Jordan, Utah

AnswerSouth Jordan, UT

No guesses; Adam's off-record hunch was New Mexico.

S4E5 β†’ S4E6 Β· Clues given February 16 Β· Revealed March 2, 2025

Millsboro, Delaware

AnswerMillsboro, DE

Wrong guesses: Cricket β€” "below the Mason-Dixon line" (no city named); Angie Raffey via YouTube β€” Rock Run, MD.

S4E4 β†’ S4E5 Β· Clues given February 2 Β· Revealed February 16, 2025

Princeton, West Virginia

AnswerPrinceton, WV

No guesses.

S4E3 β†’ S4E4 Β· Clues given January 19 Β· Revealed February 2, 2025

York, Pennsylvania

AnswerYork, PA

πŸ† Winner: Matt Robinson β€” finally congratulated by his correct name, after Michael's running Matt/Mark confusion.

β€” Season Three β€”
S3E27 β†’ S4E3 Β· Clues given December 22, 2024 Β· Revealed January 19, 2025

Spokane, Washington

AnswerSpokane, WA

Franklin Johnson's wrong "Spokane" guess for Seneca inspired Michael to make it the next city. Only guess: Adam β€” "something north" (technically the upper 50%).

S3E26 β†’ S3E27 Β· Clues given December 8 Β· Revealed December 22, 2024

Seneca, South Carolina

AnswerSeneca, SC

Wrong guess: Franklin Johnson β€” Spokane, WA, awarded a sixth of a point for getting the first letter right.

S3E25 β†’ S3E26 Β· Clues given November 24 Β· Revealed December 8, 2024

Burlington, Ontario

AnswerBurlington, Ontario

The first Canadian spotlight. Facebook bonus hint: the Great White North album cover β€” all Ontarians, Geddy Lee included. No correct guesses; Stephen would only say "Canadian money is where my mouth is."

S3E24 β†’ S3E25 Β· Clues given November 10 Β· Revealed November 24, 2024

Sacramento, California

AnswerSacramento, CA

Credit: Matt Robinson β€” Placerville, CA, ~50 miles off (and called "Mark" again). Late full answers from a private-text friend and Stephen Witts, Bushmills 16 on standby.

S3E23 β†’ S3E24 Β· Clues given October 27 Β· Revealed November 10, 2024

Pagosa Springs, Colorado

AnswerPagosa Springs, CO

Wrong guess: Matt Robinson β€” Huntsville, AL (NASA-plus-springs logic). Same episode, Michael unveiled his own spotlight page on the CMOL website.

S3E22 β†’ S3E23 Β· Clues given October 13 Β· Revealed October 27, 2024 β€” the Halloween episode

Columbus, Ohio

AnswerColumbus, OH

Adam texted Michael a confident secret guess after recording: St. Louis. Wrong twice over β€” a Michigan man bested by Ohio.

S3E21 β†’ S3E22 Β· Clues given September 29 Β· Revealed October 13, 2024 β€” the Maria Parker episode

Dubuque, Iowa

AnswerDubuque, IA

Wrong guess: Matt Robinson β€” Soda Springs, ID, admitting he'd hit his ChatGPT question limit.

S3E20 β†’ S3E21 Β· Clues given September 15 β€” the 50th episode Β· Revealed September 29, 2024

Duluth, Minnesota

AnswerDuluth, MN

Wrong guesses: Adam β€” an impulsive Boston, then "West Coast" via Jaws logic (Jaws is set in New England); and cousin Mark β€” San Pedro, CA.

S3E19 β†’ S3E20 Β· Clues given September 1 Β· Revealed September 15, 2024 β€” on the 50th

Waxhaw, North Carolina

AnswerWaxhaw, NC

πŸ† Winner: Ed β€” the 1.6Γ—-speed listener β€” with double gold stars, because it's his own town. Adam's on-air guess: Dallas, TX.

S3E18 β†’ S3E19 Β· Clues given August 18 Β· Revealed September 1, 2024

Beltsville, Maryland

AnswerBeltsville, MD

No correct guesses β€” the cryptid clue sent Adam thinking "foresty areas" and no further.

S3E17 β†’ S3E18 Β· Clues given August 4 Β· Revealed August 18, 2024

Missoula, Montana

AnswerMissoula, MT

πŸ† Winner: Steven β€” reasoning from Lewis & Clark to "what became of the acquisition." Adam guessed Denver ("there's a big rock there") despite having lived there 13 years.

S3E16 β†’ S3E17 Β· Clues given July 21 Β· Revealed August 4, 2024 β€” recorded in person before Shoreline

Sioux City, Iowa

AnswerSioux City, IA

Wrong guess: Adam β€” Albuquerque, NM. Bonus fact: George Koval, the only Soviet agent inside the Manhattan Project, was also from Sioux City.

S3E15 β†’ S3E16 Β· Clues given July 7 Β· Revealed July 21, 2024

Paris, Texas

AnswerParis, TX

Wrong guesses: Bonnie Goldberg of the Super Stragglers β€” Kansas City, MO; Steven β€” Denver, CO, via a full Paris Exposition analysis that earned style points anyway.

S3E14 β†’ S3E15 Β· Clues given June 23 β€” the BRAG wrap-up Β· Revealed July 7, 2024

Haymarket, Virginia

AnswerHaymarket, VA

No guesses β€” though the golf clue had Adam packing his bags and pricing timeshares.

S3E12 β†’ S3E13 Β· Clues given May 26 Β· Revealed June 16, 2024 β€” BRAG Part One

Seattle, Washington

AnswerSeattle, WA

πŸ† Winner: Steven Witts β€” first tempted by Vancouver, Canada, until he remembered the clues said an American town.

S3E11 β†’ S3E12 Β· Clues given May 12 Β· Revealed May 26, 2024

Owensboro, Kentucky

AnswerOwensboro, KY

πŸ† Winner: Johnny Lampkin β€” his own hometown, answered backward with receipts. The FIRST listener ever to solve a spotlight.

S3E10 β†’ S3E11 Β· Clues given April 28 Β· Revealed May 12, 2024

Reno, Nevada

AnswerReno, NV

No guesses β€” but the reveal ran long on Mary Ann appreciation.

S3E9 β†’ S3E10 Β· Clues given April 14 Β· Revealed April 28, 2024

Westbrook, Maine

AnswerWestbrook, ME

No guesses β€” Adam wandered the Kentucky-Tennessee-Illinois tri-corner and never got out.

S3E8 β†’ S3E9 Β· Clues given March 31 Β· Revealed April 14, 2024

Tucson, Arizona

AnswerTucson, AZ

Adam's trail of thought went straight to Puerto Rico and stalled there.

S3E7 β†’ S3E8 Β· Clues given March 17 Β· Revealed March 31, 2024

Dublin, Ireland

AnswerDublin, Ireland

The segment's first international city. Adam's official guess: St. Louis. His own review: "How far away could you be?"

S3E6 β†’ S3E7 Β· Clues given March 3 Β· Revealed March 17, 2024 β€” St. Patrick's Day

Starkville, Mississippi

AnswerStarkville, MS

Adam went 0-for-3: Pittsburgh and St. Louis by text, Louisville, KY on air. A listener 15 miles away wrote in delighted afterward.

S3E5 β†’ S3E6 Β· Clues given February 18 Β· Revealed March 3, 2024 β€” the first clue mystery

Lewisville, Texas

AnswerLewisville, TX

The guessing game began here β€” Michael: "You've got to play a little Sherlock Holmes." Adam's guess: "somewhere in Georgia" (cotton gin logic).

S3E4 Β· February 4, 2024 β€” the Listener Spotlight is born

Durango, Iowa & Big Lake, Minnesota

AnswerThe originals β€” spotlighted, never mysteries

Two episodes later the clues arrived, and the guessing game every episode ends with today grew from here.

"Can anyone say St. Louis?"
β€” Adam's official guess, every episode, until it's finally right

Archive complete β€” every Listener Spotlight from the segment's birth (February 4, 2024) to today.

Play Along

Make Your Guess

Think you've cracked the current mystery? Drop your guess here β€” nail it and you'll earn a shout-out in the winner's circle on a future episode.